| Date | Location | Result | |
| May 25, 2009 | Grand Chute, Wis. | St. Thomas (Minn.) 3, Carthage 1 | Box score |
| May 24, 2009 | Grand Chute, Wis. | Carthage 9, Shenandoah 8 | Box score |
| May 23, 2009 | Grand Chute, Wis. | Carthage 10, Trinity College 1 | Box score |
| May 22, 2009 | Grand Chute, Wis. | Wooster 8, Carthage 1 | Box score |
| May 18, 2009 | Moline, Ill. | Carthage 8, UW-Whitewater 3 | Box score |
| May 18, 2009 | Moline, Ill. | UW-Whitewater 4, Carthage 2 | Box score |
| May 16, 2009 | Moline, Ill. | Carthage 12, Millsaps 5 | Box score |
| May 16, 2009 | Moline, Ill. | Carthage 21, Washington (Mo.) 3 | Box score |
| May 14, 2009 | Moline, Ill. | Carthage 8, Fontbonne 7 | Box score |
| May 9, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 12, Wheaton (Ill.) 3 | Box score |
| May 8, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 16, Illinois Wesleyan 11 | Box score |
| May 7, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 12, Augustana (Ill.) 5 | Box score |
| May 5, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Concordia (Chicago) 13, Carthage 6 | Box score |
| May 3, 2009 | Elmhurst, Ill. | Carthage 10, Elmhurst 5 | Box score |
| May 2, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 17, Elmhurst 3 | Box score |
| May 2, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 3, Elmhurst 1 | Box score |
| Apr 29, 2009 | Naperville, Ill. | Carthage 12, North Central (Ill.) 2 | Box score |
| Apr 28, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 8, North Central (Ill.) 6 | Box score |
| Apr 28, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 1, North Central (Ill.) 0 | Box score |
| Apr 23, 2009 | Mequon, Wis. | Carthage 15, Concordia (Wis.) 10 | Box score |
| Apr 22, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 7, Lakeland 2 | Box score |
| Apr 18, 2009 | Moline, Ill. | Carthage 7, Augustana (Ill.) 5 | Box score |
| Apr 18, 2009 | Moline, Ill. | Carthage 6, Augustana (Ill.) 4 | Box score |
| Apr 15, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 12, Marian (Wis.) 2 | Box score |
| Apr 15, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 11, Marian (Wis.) 6 | Box score |
| Apr 11, 2009 | Bloomington, Ill. | Illinois Wesleyan 1, Carthage 0 | Box score |
| Apr 11, 2009 | Bloomington, Ill. | Carthage 3, Illinois Wesleyan 2 | Box score |
| Apr 10, 2009 | Bloomington, Ill. | Carthage 3, Illinois Wesleyan 2 | Box score |
| Apr 8, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 5, North Park 2 | Box score |
| Apr 8, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 12, North Park 1 | Box score |
| Apr 7, 2009 | Loves Park, Ill. | Carthage 10, Rockford 5 | Box score |
| Apr 4, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 16, Millikin 6 | Box score |
| Apr 4, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 4, Millikin 3 | Box score |
| Apr 1, 2009 | Chicago, Ill. | Carthage 13, North Park 8 | Box score |
| Mar 27, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 13, Wheaton (Ill.) 6 | Box score |
| Mar 26, 2009 | Schaumburg, Ill. | Carthage 7, Wheaton (Ill.) 4 | Box score |
| Mar 26, 2009 | Schaumburg, Ill. | Carthage 8, Wheaton (Ill.) 3 | Box score |
| Mar 22, 2009 | North Port, Fla. | Carthage 8, UW-Whitewater 6 | Box score |
| Mar 21, 2009 | North Port, Fla. | Carthage 4, Otterbein 1 | Box score |
| Mar 20, 2009 | North Port, Fla. | Otterbein 6, Carthage 1 | Box score |
| Mar 20, 2009 | North Port, Fla. | UW-Whitewater 9, Carthage 0 | Box score |
| Mar 17, 2009 | North Port, Fla. | Carthage 15, Minnesota-Duluth 2 | Box score |
| Mar 17, 2009 | North Port, Fla. | Southwest Minnesota 6, Carthage 3 | Box score |
| Mar 16, 2009 | North Port, Fla. | Wooster 9, Carthage 5 | Box score |
| Mar 15, 2009 | North Port, Fla. | Carthage 13, Lakeland 2 | Box score |
| Mar 14, 2009 | North Port, Fla. | Carthage 21, Becker 0 | Box score |
| Mar 14, 2009 | North Port, Fla. | Carthage 11, Ohio Wesleyan 7 | Box score |