| Date | Location | Result | |
| Apr 23, 2009 | Oberlin, Ohio | Carthage 14, Oberlin 13 | Box score |
| Apr 19, 2009 | Adrian, Mich. | Adrian 22, Carthage 6 | Box score |
| Apr 11, 2009 | Kenosha, WI | Mount St Joesph 16, Carthage 6 | Box score |
| Mar 28, 2009 | Angola, Ind., | Trine 18, Carthage 8 | Box score |
| Mar 19, 2009 | Conway, Ark. | Carthage 8, Hendrix 4 | Box score |
| Mar 18, 2009 | Birmingham, Ala. | Birmingham-Southern 14, Carthage 6 | Box score |
| Mar 16, 2009 | Birmingham, Ala. | Washington&Jefferson 9, Carthage 8 | Box score |
| Mar 7, 2009 | St. Louis, Mo. | Fontbonne 8, Carthage 3 | Box score |
| Feb 28, 2009 | Gwynedd Valley, Pa. | Gwynedd-Mercy 5, Carthage 4 | Box score |
| Feb 26, 2009 | Gwynedd Valley, Pa. | Carthage 10, Alvernia 8 | Box score |