Carthage Men’s Soccer Honors and Awards

National Soccer Coaches Association of America All-Regional

1995	Mike Domin, second team
1996	Mike Domin, second team Bart Pryputniewicz, second team
1997	Mike Domin, second team
1999	Brent Malmstrom, third team
2007	Brian Santella, second team Chris Fidlow, third team Greg Goldsberry, third team

National Soccer Coaches Association of America All-Wisconsin

1998	Brent Malmstrom, second team Bart Pryputniewicz, second team
1999	Brent Malmstrom, first team Jon Purcell, second team
2001	Jon Purcell, second team
2002	B.J. Seward, third team
2003	Jay Sikorski, third team
2004	C.J. Bachmann, third team
2005	Mike Brown, second team Gary Mouradian, third team
2006	Max Zbilut, second team Chris Fidlow, honorable mention
2007	Brian Santella, first team Chris Fidlow, second team Greg Goldsberry, second team Andy Connor, honorable mention

“d3kicks.com” All-Regional

2007	Brian Santella, third team

CCIW "Player of the Year"

1997	Mike Domin (co-player with Wheaton's Scott Brown)

All-CCIW

1995	Tony Curatolo, midfielder Mike Domin, forward Ben Gramke, midfielder
1996	Paul Bruni, defender Matt Cherney, goalie Greg Dirkse, defender Mike Domin, forward Brad O'Sullivan, forward Bart Pryputniewicz, forward
1997	Matt Cherney, goalie Mike Domin, forward Brent Malmstrom, midfielder Andy Mogg, defender
1998	Brent Malmstrom, first team, midfielder Bart Pryputniewicz, first team, forward Tim Burke, second team, midfielder
1999	Jon Purcell, first team, midfielder Brent Malmstrom, second team, midfielder Andy Mogg, second team, defender
2000	Brent Malmstrom, first team, midfielder Jon Purcell, second team, forward
2001	Jon Purcell, second team, midfielder Jay Sikorski, second team, defender
2002	Mike Brown, second team, defender B.J. Seward, second team, midfielder
2003	Jay Sikorski, second team, defender Max Zbilut, second team, forward
2004	Drew Baker, second team, goal keeper Mike Brown, second team, defender
2005	Drew Baker, second team goal keeper Mike Brown, second team, defender
2006	Max Zbilut, first team, midfielder Andy Connor, second team, goal keeper Chris Fidlow, second team, midfielder Pat Walsh, second team, defender
2007	Brian Santella, first team, forward Pat Walsh, first team, defender Andy Connor, second team, goal keeper Chris Fidlow, second team, midfielder Greg Goldsberry, second team, forward

CCIW/Joe Bean "Men’s Soccer Coach of the Year"

1996	Steve Domin
2007	Steve Domin

CCIW “Jack Swartz All-Academic”

Team “Most Valuable Players”