| Date | Location | Result | |
| Apr 4, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 3, MSOE 0 (30-18,30-25,30-26) | Box score |
| Mar 28, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | St. Ambrose 3, Carthage 0 (30-27,32-30,30-23) | Box score |
| Mar 28, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 3, Fontbonne 0 (30-9,30-18,30-12) | Box score |
| Mar 27, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 3, Quincy 2 (25-30,23-30,34-32,30-25,15-11) | Box score |
| Mar 25, 2009 | Milwaukee, Wis. | Carthage 3, MSOE 2 (25-30,30-27,28-30,30-22,15-13) | Box score |
| Mar 17, 2009 | Muncie, Ind. | Ball State 3, Carthage 0 (30-23,30-23,32-30) | Box score |
| Mar 14, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Nazareth 3, Carthage 1 (25-30,30-27,30-22,30-25) | Box score |
| Mar 14, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | New York University 3, Carthage 1 (30-26,30-32,30-25,30-20) | Box score |
| Mar 13, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | UC-Santa Cruz 3, Carthage 1 (30-19,26-30,34-32,30-17) | Box score |
| Mar 13, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Philadelpia Bible 3, Carthage 0 (32-30,30-11,30-26) | Box score |
| Mar 11, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Clarke 3, Carthage 1 (26-30,30-21,30-21,30-28) | Box score |
| Mar 6, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Lindenwood 3, Carthage 0 (30-26,30-26,30-17) | Box score |
| Mar 4, 2009 | Milwaukee, Wis. | Cardinal Stritch 3, Carthage 1 (30-27,30-28,29-31,30-24) | Box score |
| Feb 24, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Cardinal Stritch 3, Carthage 1 (30-23,27-30,30-21,31-29) | Box score |
| Feb 21, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Ball State 3, Carthage 0 (30-20,30-21,30-19) | Box score |
| Feb 14, 2009 | Rochester, N.Y. | Nazareth 3, Carthage 0 (30-17,30-19,30-28) | Box score |
| Feb 14, 2009 | Rochester, N.Y. | UC-Santa Cruz 3, Carthage 1 (28-30,30-24,30-24,30-21) | Box score |
| Feb 13, 2009 | Rochester, N.Y. | Vassar 3, Carthage 1 (30-26,28-30,30-28,30-24) | Box score |
| Feb 13, 2009 | Rochester, N.Y. | Stevens Institute 3, Carthage 0 (30-19,30-28,30-19) | Box score |
| Feb 10, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Lewis 3, Carthage 0 (30-24,30-21,30-22) | Box score |
| Feb 3, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 3, MSOE 0 (30-22,30-18,30-24) | Box score |
| Jan 31, 2009 | Davenport, Iowa | Park 3, Carthage 0 (30-28,30-26,30-25) | Box score |
| Jan 31, 2009 | Davenport, Iowa | St. Ambrose 3, Carthage 0 (30-25,30-22,30-20) | Box score |
| Jan 30, 2009 | Dubuque, Iowa | Clarke 3, Carthage 0 (30-24,30-23,30-21) | Box score |
| Jan 25, 2009 | Quincy, Ill. | Quincy 3, Carthage 0 (30-28,30-28,30-24) | Box score |
| Jan 24, 2009 | St. Charles, Mo. | Lindenwood 3, Carthage 2 (28-30,27-30,30-23,30-21,15-12) | Box score |
| Jan 24, 2009 | St. Louis, Mo. | Carthage 3, Fontbonne 0 (30-19,30-19,30-17) | Box score |
| Jan 21, 2009 | Romeoville, Ill. | Lewis 3, Carthage 0 (30-20,30-19,30-18) | Box score |
| Jan 18, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 3, Rivier 2 (28-30,33-31,30-22,38-40,15-13) | Box score |
| Jan 18, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Baruch 3, Carthage 1 (20-30,30-26,30-22,30-17) | Box score |
| Jan 17, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Endicott 3, Carthage 1 (16-30,30-28,30-28,30-27) | Box score |
| Jan 17, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 3, Medaille 0 (30-16,30-16,30-24) | Box score |
| Jan 14, 2009 | Chicago, Ill. | Loyola (Ill.) 3, Carthage 0 (30-22,31-29,30-28) | Box score |