| Date | Location | Result | |
| Nov 1, 2009 | Bloomington, Ill. | Illinois Wesleyan 1, Carthage 0 | Box score |
| Oct 25, 2009 | Collegeville, Minn. | St. Benedict 2, Carthage 0 | Box score |
| Oct 24, 2009 | Blaine, Minn. | Carthage 8, Finlandia 0 | Box score |
| Oct 21, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Elmhurst 2, Carthage 0 | Box score |
| Oct 14, 2009 | Decatur, Ill. | Millikin 2, Carthage 1 | Box score |
| Oct 17, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | North Central (Ill.) 2, Carthage 1 | Box score |
| Oct 9, 2009 | Wheaton, Ill. | Wheaton (Ill.) 4, Carthage 0 | Box score |
| Sep 30, 2009 | Dubuque, Iowa | Carthage 2, Dubuque 1 | Box score |
| Sep 26, 2009 | Chicago, Ill. | North Park 5, Carthage 4 | Box score |
| Sep 23, 2009 | Lake Forest, Ill. | Carthage 1, Lake Forest 0 | Box score |
| Sep 19, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Augustana (Ill.) 5, Carthage 1 | Box score |
| Sep 16, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carroll (Wis.) 2, Carthage 1 | Box score |
| Sep 13, 2009 | Northfield, Minn. | Carleton 3, Carthage 0 | Box score |
| Sep 12, 2009 | Northfield,Minn. | St. Olaf 2, Carthage 1 | Box score |
| Sep 10, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 3, Concordia (Wis.) 0 | Box score |
| Sep 5, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 3, Clarke 2 | Box score |
| Sep 4, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 2, St. Norbert 1 | Box score |
| Sep 1, 2009 | Winter Park, Fla. | Rollins 2, Carthage 0 | Box score |