| Singles competition |
| 1. T. Suthijindawong (SCHOLAS) def. Beth Kaufman (CARTHAGE) 6-0, 6-1 |
| 2. Gina Klein (CARTHAGE) def. Katie Motley (SCHOLAS) 6-3, 6-4 |
| 3. Taylor Gustafson (CARTHAGE) def. Callee Conda (SCHOLAS) 6-4, 6-4 |
| 4. Natalie Urick (SCHOLAS) def. Kati Hornick (CARTHAGE) 6-3, 7-5 |
| 5. Kelly Ross (SCHOLAS) def. Emily Murphy (CARTHAGE) 5-7, 6-0, 10-7 |
| 6. Jennifer Immen (CARTHAGE) def. Paula Beckermann (SCHOLAS), by default |
| Doubles competition |
| 1. Gina Klein/Taylor Gustafson (CARTHAGE) def. T. Suthijindawong/Callee Conda (SCHOLAS) 8-6 |
| 2. Katie Motley/Paula Beckermann (SCHOLAS) def. Beth Kaufman/Emily Murphy (CARTHAGE) 8-5 |
| 3. Kati Hornick/Hollis McPeek (CARTHAGE) def. Natalie Urick/Kelly Ross (SCHOLAS) 8-3 |
| Match Notes |
| St. Scholastica 9-6 |
| Carthage 10-8 |
| 2009 Intercollegiate Tennis Association Midwest Tournament first-round match |
| played at Wisconsin-Madison |