| Date | Location | Result | |
| Nov 10, 2005 | Oshkosh, Wis. | UW-Oshkosh 3, Carthage 2 (27-30,30-19,30-22,25-30,15-13) | Box score |
| Nov 5, 2005 | Kenosha, Wis. | Elmhurst 3, Carthage 1 (30-28,30-27,25-30,32-30) | Box score |
| Nov 4, 2005 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 3, Wheaton (Ill.) 0 (30-19,30-19,30-26) | Box score |
| Nov 1, 2005 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 3, North Park 0 (30-20,30-17,30-13) | Box score |
| Oct 29, 2005 | Springfield, Ohio | Carthage 3, Mount Union 0 (30-23,30-16,30-21) | Box score |
| Oct 29, 2005 | Springfield, Ohio | Carthage 3, Carnigie Mellon 0 (30-14,30-25,30-20) | Box score |
| Oct 28, 2005 | Springfield, Ohio | Wittenberg 3, Carthage 0 (30-12,30-23,30-24) | Box score |
| Oct 28, 2005 | Springfield, Ohio | Baldwin-Wallace 3, Carthage 0 (30-23,30-26,30-24) | Box score |
| Oct 27, 2005 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 3, Univ. of Chicago 2 (28-30,30-24,30-21,26-30,15-7) | Box score |
| Oct 25, 2005 | Lake Forest, Ill. | Carthage 3, Lake Forest 1 (26-30,30-21,31-29,30-18) | Box score |
| Oct 22, 2005 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 3, Wisconsin Lutheran 0 (30-19,30-19,30-18) | Box score |
| Oct 22, 2005 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 3, Rockford 0 (30-19,30-17,30-15) | Box score |
| Oct 21, 2005 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 3, Ripon 0 (30-25,30-16,30-14) | Box score |
| Oct 21, 2005 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 3, Marian (Wis.) 0 (30-25,30-10,39-15) | Box score |
| Oct 18, 2005 | Elmhurst, Ill. | Carthage 3, Elmhurst 0 (30-25,30-28,30-24) | Box score |
| Oct 15, 2005 | Elmhurst, Ill. | Carthage 3, Calvin 1 (25-30,30-25,30-22,30-26) | Box score |
| Oct 15, 2005 | Elmhurst, Ill. | UW-Whitewater 3, Carthage 0 (30-23,31-29,30-28) | Box score |
| Oct 14, 2005 | Elmhurst, Ill. | Carthage 3, Lakeland 1 (30-18,30-17,24-30,30-24) | Box score |
| Oct 14, 2005 | Elmhurst, Ill. | UW-Platteville 3, Carthage 0 (31-29,30-19,30-23) | Box score |
| Oct 8, 2005 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 3, Millikin 1 (22-30,30-26,30-27,30-16) | Box score |
| Oct 7, 2005 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 3, Illinois Wesleyan 0 (30-27,30-25,30-25) | Box score |
| Oct 4, 2005 | Naperville, Ill. | Carthage 3, North Central 2 (24-30,30-24,31-33,30-26,15-10) | Box score |
| Sep 30, 2005 | Rock Island, Ill. | Carthage 3, Augustana (Ill.) 0 (30-27,34-32,30-25) | Box score |
| Sep 27, 2005 | Chicago, Ill. | Carthage 3, North Park 0 (30-20,30-24,30-23) | Box score |
| Sep 20, 2005 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 3, Wheaton (Ill.) 0 (30-23,30-27,30-22) | Box score |
| Sep 17, 2005 | Ripon, Wis. | Carthage 3, Cardinal Stritch 0 (30-16,30-22,30-23) | Box score |
| Sep 17, 2005 | Ripon, Wis. | Carthage 3, St. Norbert 0 (30-27,30-28,30-25) | Box score |
| Sep 16, 2005 | Ripon, Wis. | Carthage 3, Carroll (Wis.) 0 (30-14,30-14,30-26) | Box score |
| Sep 16, 2005 | Ripon, Wis. | Carthage 3, Ripon 0 (30-17,30-22,30-18) | Box score |
| Sep 10, 2005 | Winona, Minn. | UW-Oshkosh 3, Carthage 1 (30-28,30-25,26-30,30-25) | Box score |
| Sep 10, 2005 | Winona, Minn. | Carthage 3, Wartburg 0 (30-28,31-29,30-19) | Box score |
| Sep 9, 2005 | Winona, Minn. | Carthage 3, UW-Superior 1 (26-30,30-20,30-22,30-28) | Box score |
| Sep 9, 2005 | Winona, Minn. | Carthage 3, Saint Mary's (Minn.) 0 (30-26,30-23,33-31) | Box score |
| Sep 3, 2005 | Elmhurst, Ill. | Carthage 3, Simpson 2 (30-24,28-30,29-31,30-15,15-8) | Box score |
| Sep 3, 2005 | Elmhurst, Ill. | Carthage 3, Univeristy of Dubuqu 0 (30-13,30-22,30-26) | Box score |
| Sep 2, 2005 | Elmhurst, Ill. | Carthage 3, Univ. of Chicago 1 (30-27,30-8,18-30,30-14) | Box score |
| Sep 2, 2005 | Elmhurst, Ill. | Carthage 3, UW-River Falls 1 (30-21,30-18,23-30,30-16) | Box score |