| Date | Location | Result | |
| Nov 7, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 3, North Central (Ill.) 0 (25-15,25-14,25-12) | Box score |
| Nov 6, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 3, Elmhurst 0 (25-13,25-19,25-21) | Box score |
| Nov 3, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 3, North Park 0 (25-10,25-12,25-7) | Box score |
| Oct 31, 2009 | Whitewater, Wis. | Carthage 3, UW-Platteville 1 (24-26,25-17,25-18,25-10) | Box score |
| Oct 31, 2009 | Whitewater, Wis. | Carthage 3, Simpson 1 (25-22,15-25,25-16,25-22) | Box score |
| Oct 30, 2009 | Whitewater, Wis. | Carthage 3, UW-Whitewater 2 (24-26,25-21,25-22,16-25,15-13) | Box score |
| Oct 30, 2009 | Whitewater, Wis. | St. Ambrose 3, Carthage 1 (28-30,25-19,25-23,25-23) | Box score |
| Oct 28, 2009 | Decatur, Ill. | Carthage 3, Millikin 2 (25-21,21-25,25-19,16-25,15-11) | Box score |
| Oct 24, 2009 | Tiffin, Ohio | Carthage 3, Heidelberg 0 (26-24,25-15,25-22) | Box score |
| Oct 24, 2009 | Tiffin, Ohio | Wittenberg 3, Carthage 1 (25-10,25-23,17-25,25-22) | Box score |
| Oct 23, 2009 | Tiffin, Ohio | Carthage 3, Webster 0 (25-16,25-18,25-15) | Box score |
| Oct 20, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 3, Illinois Wesleyan 0 (25-12,25-14,25-17) | Box score |
| Oct 17, 2009 | Oshkosh, Wis. | Carthage 3, Luther 1 (25-21,25-27,25-21,25-19) | Box score |
| Oct 17, 2009 | Oshkosh, Wis. | Carthage 3, Eastern 1 (25-18,23-25,25-15,25-8) | Box score |
| Oct 16, 2009 | Oshkosh, Wis. | Carthage 3, Lakeland 0 (25-13,25-8,25-22) | Box score |
| Oct 16, 2009 | Oshkosh, Wis. | St. Thomas (Minn.) 3, Carthage 2 (17-25,25-23,25-22,24-26,15-12) | Box score |
| Oct 13, 2009 | Elmhurst, Ill. | Carthage 3, Elmhurst 0 (25-16,25-16,25-16) | Box score |
| Oct 6, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 3, Wheaton (Ill.) 0 (25-20,25-13,25-20) | Box score |
| Oct 3, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 3, Judson (Ill.) 0 (25-19,25-17,25-14) | Box score |
| Sep 29, 2009 | Chicago, Ill. | Carthage 3, North Park 0 (25-17,25-10,25-12) | Box score |
| Sep 26, 2009 | Whitewater, Wis. | Carthage 3, Iowa Wesleyan 0 (25-9,25-13,25-17) | Box score |
| Sep 26, 2009 | Whitewater, Wis. | Carthage 3, UW-La Crosse 0 (25-15,25-19,25-10) | Box score |
| Sep 25, 2009 | Whitewater, Wis. | UW-Whitewater 3, Carthage 0 (29-27,29-27,25-21) | Box score |
| Sep 25, 2009 | Whitewater, Wis. | Carthage 3, Heidelberg 0 (25-14,25-13,25-17) | Box score |
| Sep 22, 2009 | Rock Island, Ill. | Carthage 3, Augustana (Ill.) 0 (25-16,25-13,25-19) | Box score |
| Sep 19, 2009 | Indianola, Iowa | Nebraska Wesleyan 3, Carthage 1 (25-22,25-16,16-25,25-22) | Box score |
| Sep 19, 2009 | Indianola, Iowa | Carthage 3, Augsburg 0 (25-13,25-16,25-15) | Box score |
| Sep 18, 2009 | Indianola, Iowa | Carthage 3, Wartburg 0 (25-16,25-20,25-23) | Box score |
| Sep 18, 2009 | Indianola, Iowa | Carthage 3, Bethel (Minn.) 1 (25-11,22-25,25-17,25-15) | Box score |
| Sep 15, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 3, North Central 0 (25-7,25-20,25-12) | Box score |
| Sep 11, 2009 | Platteville, Wis. | Carthage 3, UW-Platteville 0 (25-23,26-24,25-19) | Box score |
| Sep 11, 2009 | Platteville, Wis. | Carthage 3, Coe 0 (25-12,25-13,25-14) | Box score |
| Sep 7, 2009 | Claremont, Calif. | Carthage 3, Claremont-Mudd-Scrip 0 (25-20,25-18,25-18) | Box score |
| Sep 7, 2009 | Claremont, Calif. | Carthage 3, La Verne 2 (21-25,25-21,24-26,25-15,15-7) | Box score |
| Sep 7, 2009 | Claremont, Calif. | Carthage 3, Pomona-Pitzer 0 (25-22,25-16,25-9) | Box score |
| Sep 7, 2009 | Claremont, Calif. | Carthage 3, UC-Santa Cruz 0 (25-19,25-16,25-22) | Box score |