|
Volume 130, Issue 5 | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| |||||
Obama |
|
Ryan Geary
Obama has less experience debating than McCain, but that did not prevent him from being forthcoming and assertive. Some critics questioned Obama's "Plans of Change," and now they have a better idea why Obama is the only choice for president. Obama said his ideas for proposals are beneficial to taxpaying homeowners and will also prevent and stop corporate loopholes and tax cuts. He was very decisive and specific when he spoke about the possible solutions for the financial crisis. As the crisis was brought up, Obama said he was optimistic about a plan and said the government should be more responsible in helping Main Street, not just Wall Street. Obama was very knowledgeable when it came to foreign affairs. He noted that the United States soldiers were sent to the Middle East to fight Al-Qaeda, and once the forces were reduced in Afghanistan and sent to Iraq, Al-Qaeda expanded its network to 60 countries. Mark Petering of the Music Faculty commented on Obama's insight to foreign affairs: "[His] overall world- view takes into account a bigger picture than Iraq...it is necessary to have a president that does not have tunnel vision and sees how we have to handle world problems responsibly." McCain's responses to Obama's opinions were lackluster, and his notes concerning Obama's record were, at times, completely unfounded. Obama fended off all accusations, and prevented McCain from taking away momentum from his responses. Given that the topics of future debates are healthcare and domestic issues, it will be thrilling to see Obama prove McCain wrong again. |
McCain |
|
Adam Luedtke
The first half of the debate was about the current financial crisis, and although Democratic candidate Sen. Barack Obama, D-Ill. continually tried to tie McCain to President George W. Bush's policies, McCain provided bipartisan beliefs about the situation. McCain made strong points about accountability in politics and on Wall Street when it came to the economy and condemned excess and greed and how they are rewarded in today's system. While both candidates declared the need to rein in out of control spending, McCain's major point was that he has a track record of fighting excess spending while Obama does not. In fact, Obama's brief record as a senator was the most liberal of any during his time. The second half of the debate centered on foreign affairs and national security, two issues that were clearly strong points for McCain over Obama. McCain made a strong case for his experience involving these issues and the lack of experience on Obama's part. This point was particularly made on McCain's grasp of the severity of ending the Iraq War the right way, with victory and honor. Obama wants to pull out of Iraq, which may lead to further, more expansive and expensive wars. McCain was in Vietnam and knows the effect a lost war can have on the country. While lots of college students may have come away with an impression of Obama winning the debate because of his speaking skills and youth, McCain clearly had better answers when it came to the economy and foreign affairs, and answers is what this country seemingly needs. |
Number of visitors to the website.